Follow me on Twitter

Blog archive

We Participate In:

ABA Journal Blawg 100!







Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Login

Simple Jury Persuasion: Look inside at the very best ‘you’ there is…

Friday, January 1, 2010
posted by Douglas Keene

How do you get jurors to truly set aside their biases and deliberate from a place of fairness and tolerance? In 2000, Wendy Wood published a review of literature on social influence and message-based persuasion.  We think they are truly relevant to litigation advocacy and we want to focus on two findings in particular (from Pool et al., 1998 and Abrams & Hogg, 1988).

According to Wood, Pool et al., (1998) finds we agree with people we favor. Another way of saying this is that we are influenced by our desire to be like those whom we admire, value, see positively and respect.

Wood sees Abrams & Hogg’s (1988) work as concluding that we also are influenced to change our attitudes by a desire “to be true to oneself and to achieve a coherent, certain self-view”. In other words, we want to see ourselves as reliable and consistent, values that most people rank highly.

So how do you use this in litigation advocacy?  First, know that it is safe to encourage jurors to be the best version of themselves.  Second, encourage them to set aside bias, hatred, superiority, jealousy, racism, ageism, sexism, and pretty much any other ‘ism’ you can call to mind. We’ve seen this strategy used by a masterful attorney friend in Houston over the years and it could go something like this in a closing statement:

“I want you to close your eyes with me and picture a parent who loves his or her child. And that child grows up and makes some mistakes along the way as we all do.  The loving parent recognizes that like all of us, the child is imperfect and struggling, and in spite of his special needs he has hopes and dreams like we all do.  And so the parent devotes untold hours per day, every day, for years.  Then one day that parent is horribly hurt and the now-grown child is left alone to be cared for by relatives. When you look inside yourself at the very best ‘you’ there is, should it make a difference when you open your eyes if that child you see in front of you is black (or old, or Hispanic, or disabled, or disfigured, or poor)?  Of course not.  Because a child, even when grown, is still a child.  And needs must be met.”

Our client is a master.  Even when we know it’s coming, we tear up. The message is delivered solemnly, quietly and almost musingly to the jury. The case narrative is encapsulated into a few sentences and the ‘hook’ is a direct invitation to set aside our biases.

It is an invitation to be the best we are. To align ourselves with those we admire rather than acting out of our own petty biases and fears. It is a call to arms and a call to arms of the best aspects of our selves. We want to see ourselves positively. We want to feel good about what we do. And on a jury, we want to right wrongs.

Abrams D. and Hogg, M.A. (1988). Comments on the motivational status of self-esteem in social identity and intergroup discrimination. European Journal of Social Psychology, 18:317–34.

Pool, G.J., Wood, W., and Leck, K. (1998). The self- esteem motive in social influence: agreement with valued majorities and disagreement with derogated minorities. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75:967–75.

Wood, W. (2000). Attitude Change: Persuasion and Social Influence. Annual Review of Psychology, 51:539-570.

Share


12 Responses to “Simple Jury Persuasion: Look inside at the very best ‘you’ there is…”

  1. Blawg you should be reading: The Jury Room http://t.co/emswqoc — Today's topic – does Black + Gay = Likeable?

  2. Paul Birch says:

    RT @changingminds: Keene Trial Consulting's 'Jury Room' — blog on persuading juries: http://lnkd.in/Cbs7W9

  3. Dave Straker says:

    Keene Trial Consulting's 'Jury Room' — blog on persuading juries: http://lnkd.in/Cbs7W9

  4. Alex Proaps says:

    @pourbrew Came across this blog tonight while looking at researchblogging.com under Psychology. http://bit.ly/zX49W

  5. We invite you to visit our firm blog (The Jury Room) for litigation advocacy ideas at http://keenetrial.com/blog/ (via @KeeneTrial)

  6. RT @keenetrial Simple Jury Persuasion: She reminds me of my Grandmother… http://bit.ly/9by8RI

  7. RT @KeeneTrial: Launching new blog feature Monday: Voir Dire Clinic (send us cases 4 voir dire question ideas) http://bit.ly/1YnQ4O / cool

  8. RT @KeeneTrial: New blog post: We act as we believe others expect us 2 act (clues 4 appearing confident in voir dire) http://bit.ly/1YnQ4O

  9. RT @Eline_Kullock: Generation Y: Just the facts http://migre.me/fTaM #millennials #geny

  10. RT @KeeneTrial: New blog post: Simple Persuasion Strategies: The Alpha & Omega Persuasion tactics http://bit.ly/U0rhA

  11. That is very sad. And perhaps one lesson is a comment about the re-used dress shirts–as in, “should it make a difference if the defendant wears the same dress shirt we loan to all our clients for trial?”.

    We saw similar biases/assumptions in a recent mock trial we did (see our post from December 9). I looked at the witness and saw a young woman who looked tired and much older than her years. They saw an addict who had probably done cocaine during a break in the deposition. You can’t know what jurors will use to fill in the blanks in your case narrative. All you can do is try to learn where the blanks are and offer an explanation. –Rita

  12. tc beach says:

    I’m a public defender. After I lost a trial that was deliberated for hours, I saw 4 of the jurors in the parking lot. I asked them what swayed them to convict. It was a cocaine possession case and they said that he looked gaunt in the loose fitting dress shirt. That made him look like a cocaine user. The guys in the jail get the same few dress shirts we have for trials. Sad.

Leave a Reply